Thursday, April 12

My Vonnegut


It occurred to me at some point in the last year that I should be thinking about writing a personal obituary for Kurt Vonnegut. It wasn't that I thought his passing was inevitable, I merely wanted to be prepared because I knew the moment I heard the news I probably wouldn't be able to articulate my ideas and feelings. I kept putting it off, occasionally convincing myself that it was ghoulish to believe the man didn't have more years in him, that I still had plenty of time.

Looks like I missed the deadline.

It started in my garage. In my early teens the garage became one of those in-house sanctuaries for exploration and time alone. It was there that I discovered boxes of private things my dad owned. This didn't initially strike me as odd as my parents clearly held different personal and political views and to prevent discord they defaulted to abstinence. Politics were not discussed because they supported different parties. We owned more music than books but because they had different tastes (mom dug Motown, dad was a country-folkie) it was never played. Apparently there were books belonging to my dad that didn't belong with what few books we owned in the one bookcase in the living room.

It wasn't personal taste that caused the segregation of those books, but the dangerousness of their subject matter -- Everything You Always Wanted To Know About Sex (But Were Afraid To Ask) by Dr. David Reuben and Welcome To the Monkey House by Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. It might have seemed rational with my hormones raging that I would have gravitated to the book about sex but a quick glance at its contents scared me. The book made repeated references to the sexual practices and activities of men and women, and to my teenage mind that meant adults, which included my parents, and I didn't want any unsavory mental pictures. That left me the Vonnegut to puzzle out, which I did over the course of a month's worth of bathroom visits. The bathroom was my other sanctuary and allowed me to read the book in secret. My parents probably thought I was masturbating.

The advantage of a short story collection is that you get a sampling of an author's voice and talents. While there were stories that I appreciated -- "Harrison Bergeron", "D.P." and "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow" -- I wasn't quite satisfied. I felt like there was something more, something I wasn't really getting. It was time to go to the library.

This Vonnegut person had a good smattering of books on the shelves, the most promising of which was Cat's Cradle. I pulled it down and found a nook at the edge of the adult reading room and began reading. The chapters were short, like an early chapter book, but the story was told in an almost glib voice, staccato phrasing and disjointed. I didn't get it, mostly because I was unfamiliar with the style. I put the book back and gave up on Vonnegut.

A month later in a casual conversation with a classmate named Po I found another person who'd heard of Vonnegut. No, she hadn't just heard of him, she was practically an apostle. Her older brother had hipped her to his books and she was fan enough to recount all their plots in great detail. What she told me not only rekindled my interest but was exactly the confirmation I needed to know going in: "He's a cynical bastard, Elz, you'll like him." I think that's what she said. She might have actually said "you're like him."

As luck would have it in these situations Vonnegut had a new book out called Breakfast of Champions. I had no idea what I was in for but I was determined to figure out what this Vonnegut person was all about. There were raised eyes from the ladies at the check-out counter of my library but nothing more. I had planned to wait until I got home to start reading but curiosity got the better of me. And there I was, standing in the middle of the sidewalk reading the words and looking at the pictures (pictures! juvenile scrawl in the author's own hand!) thinking: I can't believe they would publish this.

In his own way, Vonnegut casually begins his book on matters that seem tangential to the story, or offered up as background. What he's actually doing is setting up his leitmotifs and his riffs, a verbal overture if you will meant to fool you into thinking that the story's coming, soon, sooner, just wait. In Breakfast of Champions there is talk of stories being published in nudie magazines, wedged between beaver shots, and for those who might be confused he offers his own drawings of what those photos would look like followed by a drawing of the animal it is compared with. I might not have been ready to deal with the realities of sex, but this I could understand!

And then a funny thing happened: I started liking books again, started liking reading. Over the course of seven years of formal education I had slowly had the joy of reading drained and beaten out of me. The initial flush of excitement that comes from being able to read for yourself had slowly been choked by endless worksheets full of directions, SRA booklets and Ginn & Co. readers with serviceable, workman-like stories designed for comprehension questions. The encouragement to read was still there, the library talks and the individual recommendations from teachers, but the joy had been deadened. By seventh grade the materials we were being introduced to had importance and carried weight as classics (or at the very least culturally significant) but there was little fun to be extracted from the exercise of reading, much less from the subject matter.

Vonnegut gave me hope. There were adults in the world writing books that were as outrageous as the British comedy that was being exported to PBS, full of the absurdities of mankind told with a dry acerbic wit. I got it, enough to send me back to Cat's Cradle and Slaughterhouse-Five. It sent me to the drama section for a script of a PBS television adaptation of his stories called Between Time and Timbuktu. I reread the short stories with a new eye. By the time I was in eighth grade and had to write a book report/personal narrative in long-form (over 12 pages) I not only wrote in my version of Vonnegut's style, I made him a character in the report. I used to say Vonnegut taught me how to write but that's not true; Vonnegut gave me permission to borrow his voice until I could find my own, and he gave me a few hints about where to find it as well.

Vonnegut's name attached to a review in either Newsweek or Time made mention of Joseph Heller and Philip Roth. I read Catch-22 and Portnoy's Complaint as a result. Comparisons to Twain were made, but as much as I appreciate Twain's wit I never cared for the style. Understanding this didn't make it easier for me to find the kinds of voices I was looking for in literature but it did lead me down some unusual paths. I was too impatient to actually learn the finer points of craft in my own writing -- I would race to tell a story but skimp on details, butchered spelling, sucked at editing for clarity -- but I didn't let piddling details stop me. Another friend once referred to some poetry I attempted as Ginsburg-esque, an insult at the time because I wanted to be forward-looking, not beatnik. When it came time to head off to college I brought along two treasured authors: Vonnegut and Charles Bukowski.

Perfect for art school.

I suppose the death watch on Vonnegut officially begins in the mid-1980's. In the same year he published his last great book (in my opinion) Galapagos and attempted suicide. There was, in the back of my mind, a hope that one day I might be able to meet the man, that I would be in a place where we would both have something to talk about to each other. More than fanboy idolatry and perhaps something close to peer. Or master and student. But if my onset of puberty happened on-time my creative maturity has taken somewhat longer and the thought of ever being even a fledgling desciple long past. A

t a certain point when my beloved creatives began to shuffle off this mortal coil I realized my time with each of them was precious and limited. In the ever-present question of whom I would invite to a fantasy dinner for conversation the list of possible names on the roster keeps getting shorter. Up until yesterday Vonnegut's name was at the head of the table. Robert Altman was at that table until last year. Something tells me J.D. Salinger is going to bow out before I can send the invitation.

In the end I figured Vonnegut would play the wise old cuss until the very end. For all his doom and gloom he held in his heart a place for the redemption of humanity, no matter how much he argued for the other side. That is until recently. The election and re-election of George Bush and the policies and actions of the Bush administration finally broke his resolve. Here is a man who, as a US Infantryman, survived the fire bombing of Dresden in World War II and witnessed all of human history for the second half of the 20th century and could still find glimmers of hope that we weren't headed for self-destruction as a species. But for the last six years he has had that hope whittled away until finally, in his essays for In These Times (later collected in Man Without a Country) he had concluded there was no longer any reason to hold out hope.

In short, George W. Bush killed Kurt Vonnegut.

Vonnegut had anticipated dying from his addiction to cigarettes. He considered it an elegant form of suicide. Even twenty years after his official suicide attempt he was still going strong, still smoking, still unable to kill himself. Much like his faith in humans to not blow themselves into smithereens, that optimism that informed his cynicism kept him alive. Like many of us, we want to know how the movie is really going to turn out. The minute he began to feel all was lost was when he began to give up. I know he died from brain injuries suffered after a fall in his home, but somewhere in that brain the switch to fight for survival had been flipped to the off position.

In time, as with all writers, all that remains is the voice. For those who have left us many years ago the sting of that loss is dulled, if present at all. Those born today will not miss Vonnegut the person for lack of the intangible sense of having walked the Earth at the same time he did. Somehow, being alive at the time of a writer gives their voice a certain meaning, a sense of something shared. In the end the voice still carries on, in books, in recordings, in memories of speeches given. The voice is time-stamped, dated. He has said all he will ever say.
“If I should ever die, God forbid, let this be my epitaph: The only proof he needed for the existence of God was music." —Kurt Vonnegut, A Man Without a County
Good-bye, Blue Monday.

Wednesday, April 11

Grimmoire 23: The Mouse, the Bird, and the Sausage

What's not to like about animals and inanimate objects setting up house together?

This is one of those stories where the members of the house trade jobs and find they never really appreciated what the others did. Only instead of a farmer and his wife (as in Wanda Gag's Gone is Gone, among others) we have a Mouse, a Bird and a Sausage. Bird's job was to bring back wood for the fire, Mouse ported water back to their home and Sausage did the cooking.

Only the logic of a fairy tale would allow a sausage to slide through the stew just before mealtime to make sure everything was salted and seasoned. And exactly how long could a sausage be called on to flavor a meal before it was little more than flavorless meat in a casing?

After a trade of duties Sausage goes off to fetch firewood but is eating by a passing dog. When Sausage doesn't return from his chore Bird fetches the firewood, found out the dog ate her housemate, and flew back to tell Mouse. Distressed the attempt to carry on, Mouse tending the cooking. Just before serving Mouse slips into the pot to season the meal but never slips out, having become one with the stew. Bird didn't see this, and distracted at having lost two friends, inadvertently sets the house on fire. Going to fetch water Bird is dragged down the well with the bucket and drowns.

There's your cheery bedtime story, kiddies. Now sleep tight.

Grimmoire 21: Cinderella

Most decidedly not the Disney version.

No fairy godmother.
No pumpkins, no coaches, no mice.
The ball was a three-night gala.
No clock chiming at midnight.

The glass slipper was made of gold.
Cinderella's step-sisters each cut off parts of their feet in order to fit the slipper.

All these things that just get left behind in all the retellings, all this wonderful and weird and rich detail!

I cannot tell you how many times a week I see girls go straight to the princess books, many of them are under the age of five, all of them able to name the Disney princesses on sight. I think there ought to be a law that says you cannot buy young girls any books about princesses until after you've read the source material to them. Aloud. Fully explained.

Yes, tell them that when her rich father went on a trip that his stepdaughters requested he bring them back pearls and dresses but that Cinderella requested only a twig from a far-away tree that she would plant on her dead mother's grave where it will grow into a tree (explain how roots work, dearies) and how the tree grew and housed a bird that granted her wishes and prayers.

Read these small girls the story and point out that her father is rich -- she didn't need to dress in rags -- and that her self-sacrifices and obedience to her stepmother and stepsisters are what gave her strength of character. Remind them of these traits when these little princesses throw tantrums because their mothers will only buy them one or two princess books and not all of them. Point out that Cinderella only became a princess after a lengthy indentured servitude with a cruel stepmother who would make her pick out lentils thrown into the ashes of the fireplace. Maybe suggest that if these little princesses would like some more princess books they could volunteer to pick out a bowl of lentils themselves so that they know what it means to become a princess.

And here's a nice detail: In order to prevent Cinderella from running away after the third night of the gala festivities he has his servants coat the stairs with tar. This is how she loses her gold (not glass) slipper. Be sure to pause thoughtfully when relating the part about the stepsisters chopping off parts of their feet to fit the slipper they know isn't theirs. And for their wickedness and malice these stepsisters have their eyes pecked out by pigeons before and after the wedding ceremony.

Underscoring the ghastly behavior of the stepsisters equal to the story of Cinderella herself. Cinderella cannot be who she is (or becomes) without the adversity presented to her, and it is her reward, her cosmic justice if you will, that she not only gets the prince but that her sisters are deformed and mutilated for their actions without her wishing it upon them. These are not small lessons and if all a girl knows is that Cinder's stepsisters were ugly brats then there is little to learn from the tale other than "in the end she gets to wear pretty clothes all the time and dance" as one little girl I heard summarized it.

Yeah, that's what that story is all about.

Emma-Jean Lazarus Fell Out of a Tree

by Lauren Tarshis
Dial 2007

There's a crackling funkiness to this book that hooked me early on, the hissing anticipation of a very long fuse on an unseen firecracker. You watch and wait for that fuse to reach its powder keg and at the last minute it just stops.

From that you might assume that I was disappointed or that I didn't like this book. Generally that would be a correct assumption. Here though, the longer this book sits with me the more I'm beginning to believe that it very nearly achieved that difficult balance between a perfect anti-climax and a missing last chapter.

Emma-Jean is the deliberate, deceptively simple seventh grader who views life with the cool detachment of a scientist. She inherited her mannerisms either genetically or behaviorally from her father, a math professor, who has been dead a few years now. From her rational viewpoint everything can be studied and puzzled out, all problems have a logical solution.

In the bathroom a girl she is acquainted with named Colleen (she has no friends by her own admission, and none the worse for it either) is having a panic attack because her best friend Kaitlin uninvited her to a weekend ski trip to invite the queen bee Laura along instead. Emma-Jean takes in the information and the casual challenge that Colleen utters when she wishes something could be done about the situation. Emma-Jean sets about to lure Laura away from the trip so that Colleen can be re-invited. The plan is to create an official-looking document from the school inviting Laura to perform at a special ceremony for the basketball team, appealing to Laura's pride and vanity. By the time Laura figures out it was a prank the other girls are already well on their way and Laura is out for blood.

In her own subtle way Emma-Jean finds herself fond of one of these basketball players, a boy named Will, who one day she hears being slandered by a spiteful teacher. In no time she is on the case, solving the mystery behind this teacher's rage and setting about to help clear Will as well. At home, Emma-Jean and her mother have taken in a housemate named Vikram, another scientist, who may or may not have affection for Emma-Jean's mom. This idea comes to her later after she has set about finding Vikram a suitable mate in the form of her very understanding English teacher at school.

Emma-Jean's problem solving begins to turn when Laura deduces who was behind the prank and threatens to get both Emma-Jean and Colleen in trouble. The stress of having to face the wrath of Laura makes Colleen physically ill and, in an attempt to help, Emma-Jean has an accident that explains the book's title.

This is where things get dicey, as all the story elements begin to come together it is obvious that things will get cleared up and everyone will be happy. Except for Laura, who gets a good dose of Colleen's newly acquired self-confidence and is turned down at the school dance by Will. Emma-Jean does not get in trouble, Will is suddenly no longer the brunt of his teacher's anger, Vikram may or may not be the replacement for her late father, and the janitor who knows some of Emma-Jean's secrets and is himself one of her protectors lets her know that he is about to retire.

Badly handled, all of this would play a little too pat, but it doesn't make for a truly satisfying ending when all along you're waiting for things to blow. It isn't until Emma-Jean has her accident, and Colleen is dragged to her minister for a little confessional time, that I sensed things might be as satisfying as I'd hoped. After a short pep-talk, Colleen is finally able to move forward with confidence and that bothers me. Though it's Emma-Jean's story -- and she does get a little lesson in when not to meddle in others lives and how to accept the fact that she's a little distant -- it's Colleen who must make the greatest growth and (here's the problem) it doesn't come from within. Yes, she is helped to understand the idea of not being perfect, and that weakness is what being human is partly about, but to have her sudden strength given to her is a little too much like the Cowardly Lion's courage. We know it always had to be there, deep inside, but if it doesn't come out naturally then it isn't really a change of character, it's a device of plot.

I do think that Tarshis manages to capture a unique personality type in Emma-Jean, the "special" girl with the analytical abilities far beyond her emotions. The hints at a growing self-awareness within Emma-Jean would make for a fascinating character study once she's off to college, but for this book it's more quirk than anything. For seventh grade girls who deal heavily with the queen bee/wannabe social dichotomy the idea of a world outside the clique will seem foreign and weird. I don't imagine this book is for any of them but for those who may be on the cusp of having to decide whether they are in, out or beyond.

I think more than a few sixth grade boys could benefit from this story as well.

Tuesday, April 10

Grimmoire 19: The Fisherman and His Wife

Another classic tale, another Grimm story first introduced to me via the magic of the "Fractured Fairy Tales" feature on the Rocky and Bullwinkle program.

I'm sure the memory I have of it being three wishes instead of the six demands the wife makes comes from that cartoon's warped telescoping of the story, but the odd little message at the end of the Grimm version gives pause.

To recap: Fisherman finds an enchanted flounder who once was a prince in the sea. Or was he a talking flounder who was once an enchanted prince? Either way, he's a flounder, a prince, he talks, and he's enchanted. Makes me wonder about his backstory, but maybe we'll get to that tale in time. Fisherman sets the flounder free then tells his wife who upbraids him for not knowing the rules of Fairytale Land and insists he go back and demand his reward. Oh, and in case we weren't clued in that she married a dullard, wifey tells him what to ask for: a better cottage to live in. He does, and he does, returns home to find the wish granted, but it's not enough. Now she wants a castle so the fisherman returns and makes another request on behalf of his wife, and then another. After the castle she wants to be king (Not queen? Hmmm.), and after she's queen she wants to be emperor (really?) and then she wants to be pope (Pope Joan, perhaps?) finally to be like a god.

Like a god. Not god, but an incredible simulation.

This is not insignificant, because what the flounder says in the end is Go back home. She's sitting in your hovel again. For a woman who wasn't satisfied with fine homes and refined titles she got a little lesson in happiness; she and her fisherman husband aren't punished though they may believe they have been. The flounder has shown them the way of the Buddha, to live simply and humbly and not want beyond their needs. That the story is about a fisherman carries its own religious symbology and that he asks for nothing himself underscores that because the wife demanded the granting of wishes that she was in need of the lesson, which the wise, enchanted prince of a flounder was more than willing to provide.

I must confess, one of the things that comes to mind with this story is the Hope-Crosby vehicle The Road to Utopia. There's a scene where the boys are ice fishing and Bing keeps pulling out fish after fish while Bob gets nothing. After Bing leaves Bob looks down and there's a fish looking up out of the hole. Fish: Hey, where'd your buddy go? Bob: Oh, he just took off with Dorothy. Fish: Well, tell him number sixteen was here. Bob double-takes. The fish slips away. I love just love talking animals, they always seem to be smarter than humans, even when they seem to be throwing their own lives away in the process. At least in this Grimm tale the fish stays a fish and lives.

Monday, April 9

Life As We Knew It

by Susan Beth Pfeffer
Harcourt 2006

What could be more benign than the moon, cycling through the night sky, orbiting Earth and inspiring song and romance.

Bringing with it the end of life as we know it.

Miranda's journal entries quickly bring us up to speed. Her parents are separated, her father's remarried and his new young wife is newly pregnant. Her older brother is finishing up his first year at college and her younger brother thinks of nothing but baseball. Among Miranda's close friends she counts a girl enamored with her Born Again minister. Another friend died in an accident last year. Due to an injury Miranda has had to give up ice skating for swimming but she still follows the rise of a local boy on his way toward the Olympics.

Then there's all this talk -- excited talk -- about an asteroid on a collision course with the moon. The scientists have made their calculations and deemed the event historic but safe. The face of the moon has shown a history of asteroid damage and this current event promises to be spectacular, viewable with binoculars if not with the naked eye.

Miscalculation. The density of the asteroid was greater than anticipated. The moon is knocked from its orbit, closer to the Earth. Tides erupt into tsunamis all over the world. Earthquakes. Volcanoes awaken. The shoreline of every continent is swallowed. News vanishes from coastal radio and television networks. The moon sits uncomfortably close to the horizon.

Panic sets in. Miranda's mom has preservation instincts enough to grab as much cash as she can and go shopping for perishables. Miranda, her younger brother Jonny and their close family friend Mrs. Nesbit all help stockpile goods for the pantry. Miranda feels it's all a bit much, but then everyone is doing it so maybe her mom knows what she's doing. Families start to leave town, kids stop going to school. News comes in spurts from landlocked cities: rolls of the dead are read. The electricity begins to falter. The sky is covered in volcanic ash, the temperature rises, then falls sharply. How long with the heating oil and gas last? What kind of a winter is coming?

How long will Miranda and her family last?

As a member of Gen X (or the tail end of the Boomers, depending on where you set your marker) I'm one of those who have never had to learn first hand what bad times could be like. We've suffered depressions, but not like in the 20's and 30's. We've seen wars, and war protests, but it never really challenged our daily lives the way World War II brought on rationing and home front sacrifice. The Holocaust is something in history books, not living memory. I've seen my fair share of earthquakes (1971 and 1989), watched the hurricanes and tornadoes on the news, read about famine and disaster the world over. But the members of The Greatest Generation have done their job a little too well by cocooning the rest of us from the realities they vowed never to suffer again. We have not, as sheltered Americans, as world citizens en masse, had the personal experience of knowing what we would do when pressed to our limits.

Which is why some of us like reading about Earth shattering events that provoke those corners of our brains to ask "What would I do in that situation?" I couldn't make a steady diet of books and movies like that, like Life As We Knew It, but I could consume my fair share. I think many teens do, and for similar reasons -- because we want to compare our own emotions and reactions with those of the characters. We want to be right, and where we're wrong we want to know how and why. The book, movie or play become personal, we judge the characters and evaluate the situations and run a parallel narrative in our heads. Yes, hoard as much as you can, share with no one, and think about what you do when people get desperate. Can you second guess the medical concerns, the biological variables, the emotional trauma? When the food runs scarce who eats less, who eats more and who gives up all together?

I think Pfeffer has put together a great little story here, one that opens itself naturally to questions of morals and values. That alone probably prohibits it from use in the classroom (because morals and values aren't measured on standardized tests) but it shouldn't prevent whole-hearted recommendations to teens. I have a few questions and items I wish were addressed in the book -- political information, how the governments survived and some of the social mechanics of community, particularly after the first winter -- but perhaps that means I can look forward to a sequel. Honestly, there probably isn't any way to include the political in a journal reporting on a closed system like a single family's survival, still one can always hope.

Hope. Yeah, that's in there as well. The hope that Miranda can one day go to the prom, that the worst is over and that, with some adjustment, life as she once knew it will one day return.

Grimmoire 16: The Three Snake Leaves

Once upon a time there was a poor man who could no longer provide enough food for his only son...

Yes, more famine. Only this time the boy goes out into the world on his own so as not to be a burden. But let's leave this part of the story aside for this next little juicy tidbit:
The king had a daughter who was very beautiful but also very strange, for she had made a vow that she would accept as her lord and master only a man who would let himself be buried alive with her if she should die first.
Very strange indeed.

The lesson is going to fall to the king's daughter because obviously the boy is going to meet her, get buried with her alive, and somehow survive to show that such unusual and cruel demands are met with a fitting rejoinder. Yes, the boy agrees, and the princess dies, and it's while entombed that the boy sees a snake. He cuts the snake to pieces only to be amazed when another snake comes and lays three leaves on the chopped up snake to heal it and bring it back to life. The boy takes the leaves and revives his wife and -- huzzah! -- she is alive and they are released from the tomb!

And how does she repay her hubby? Well, one day they are on a voyage and she becomes enamored with the ship's captain. But what's to stop her from killing her faithful hubby and tossing him into the sea? Nothing, but the boy/husband's servant has the ability to go overboard and save him, reviving him with those snake leaves. And then they row ashore and tell the king, the strange princess's father. He cannot believe such a thing and hides his son-in-law when the princess returns.

She tells such a tale of woe, about how her husband died at sea, and has as her witness the ship's captain. King Daddy asks why she did not honor her husband the way he honored her and thrown herself overboard and then -- oops -- out pops her restored hubby.

Dad's decision is swift: she and the ship captain must sail out to sea in a boat with holes drilled into it. A long, slow, sinking death at sea, lots of time to contemplate how she ended up in that predicament and no way out.

Despite the eye-for-an-eye ending on this, I do find myself liking this tale because it speaks directly to the idea of children being demanding, ungrateful and cruel and calls them to task for it. Indulgent parents don't come off smelling so sweet either when you think of it. I come and go with my feelings about morals in fables but something about this one feels contemporary.

Five Books, Fourth Grade, 1971-1972

Recently I've found myself involved in conversations that seem to circle back to my fourth grade class reading. There were five books our teacher, Mrs. White, read aloud to us three times a week after lunch and it's taken a lot of hard thought to recall all five of those books.

What strikes me most about the assortment is just how classic the reading was and what they say about their time, or rather what they say about a generation that grew up during those times.

If ever there was a book that hit our class hardest it was Harriet the Spy. Originally published in 1964 it was possible that this book felt the most contemporary to us as witnessed by the debates that took place as we would line up for lunch. While some of us contemplated what Harriet would do next, others would speculate what would happen to Harriet while other began keeping their own little not-so-secret notebooks. My original memory was that Mrs. White did not finish reading this book hoping instead to entice us to seek out the ending on our own. But remembering the end of the book and the classroom reaction reminded me that she had indeed read it to the class.

Looking back I suspect that Mrs. White knew these girls (it was only girls) had been keeping these private Harriet-wannabe journals, and she seemed to look pointedly at all of us when Harriet's journal was exposed and the lessons were heaped up on her. Without making issue of the journals being kept in class they disappeared and were never mentioned again

Forth grade is when California history is taught, and I don't think it was coincidence that Island of the Blue Dolphins made it into our reading time. The tale of the girl Robinson Caruso helped bring to life not only the survivor tale but the lives of the native populations in a rich detail.

After studying about the California missions (including a field trip to Mission San Gabriel Archangel) I would have thought we'd all been pretty tired of any more stories of primitive peoples in (what felt to us like) prehistoric times. But if there's one thing that boy gravitate toward it's a good old fashioned tale of being stranded and fighting wild dogs and surviving by wits. And for the girls, the satisfaction of knowing that a girl could take care of herself.

This is one I've been meaning to get back to as an adult and see how much is still there in the old memory banks.

I'm not going to pretend that we didn't think Charlotte's Web was a bit of a baby story when Mrs. White began reading this to us, especially when she would pause and walk the U-shape layout of the classroom desk to show us the various illustrations. Those moments of waiting and craning to see the pictures, accompanied by the rambunctiousness of kids just in from lunch, made the natural flow of the afternoon read a bit difficult. The rule was that we had to sit quietly and we could put our heads down on the desks but absolutely nothing else. It was hard to settle in to a nice post-recess read when you've got remain alert for the pictures.

That little flaw aside, and once we got over our little "baby book" whining the book turned out to be quite good after all. I even remember at the end some of the "tougher" boys worrying about Wilbur and trying not to get all choked up about Charlotte.

I hear they made a movie out of this book, but I can't imagine why any sensible-thinking person would want to. Not everything has to be refitted for modern audiences, or made purely to line someone's wallet.

While not the original dead dog story (who gets that honor, Old Yeller?) there's no doubting that the genre wasn't as harrowing as Sounder was to our gentle minds back in the day. I'm embarrassed to admit that the details have gone soft and fuzzy for me over time, but not the image of that poor dog hiding under the house with half of his head bloodied from a shotgun blast hasn't faded all these years.

But what was running through our heads back then? I have an equally vivid memory of watching the motorcade of JFK's funeral on television, and the assassinations of MLK and RFK were still echoing in our minds, though I doubt we understood their true meanings or significance. I have this memory of a sensation that there was something wrong in our country, an awakening as it were to the dissonance between the words "Land of the free, home of the brave" and the realities on the news and in books. This is where the story of Sounder clearly sits, lodged in the same space occupying the tragedies of the late 1960's, the successes of the moon launches, the Civil Rights Movement and the slow opening of a door that lead us out of the room called innocence and into the rest of our lives.

Our last book on my little tour through fourth grade was actually a school-wide read: Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. Roald Dahl's classic story of the unusual candyman and his contest to give a tour (and a factory) as a prize for five lucky people was being adapted into a musical to be preformed by the sixth grade class. More: the adaptation was being written by our own Mr. Green who at one point in his past was a rehearsal pianist for Broadway prior to becoming a school teacher.

Memory and time can color things many different shades, but nothing can alter the reality that Mr. Green's completely faithful adaptation of Dahl's book -- down to a chorus singing Dahl's Oompa Loompa verses as transitions for scenery changes -- was brilliant. That it came the year after the movie leads me to wonder whether or not it was in reaction to the less-than-faithful adaptation with Gene Wilder (though preferred over the recent Johnny Depp version) or merely a way to grab hold of a comet and ride its tail. I do know that the show sold out every performance in our school's cafetorium to the point of standing room only. I had long hoped that Mr. Green was able to parlay the success of that show into a serious career in musical theatre but that's an adult me seeing through fourth grade eyes. By fifth grade I was at another school across town and in the years I spent in my home town I never discovered whether that was a singular event or if that was one of many shows put together by Mr. Green.

The book? Loved. And what's not to love? Underdog makes good, chocolate everywhere, bad kids get comeuppance... Dahl may have been weird but he knew what kids liked in a story. As far as I'm concerned the only thing that ruins this book are the current illustrations by Quinten Blake. I know he's Dahl's illustrator of preference and all, but you cannot take away that part of my childhood, and those include the images first put into my head by Joseph Schindelman.

I wonder what five books will reign in the memories of my girls, currently in third and fifth grade. Years from now what will be the books with greatest impact, what will they be calling classics? We had nothing like Potter-mania or hungry book publishers looking to get us to buy every movie tie-in they can manufacture. The whole culture of books and reading is different, but I can happily say that they read far more than I did at that age. But what sticks, what's going to hold sway on that one day, thirty years from now, when they sit down and write about the five books they remember most during this time?

Anyone else have any memories they'd like to share?

Sunday, April 8

Grimmoire 15: Hansel and Gretel

Whenever you reread a familiar story it's the details that tend to stand out. On first brush the details are part of the fabric of the whole, the bits and pieces you put together to make a whole image in your head. Later you see that the things you forgot add an interesting flavor to the memories.

Famine would have been a very realy fear for people and here runs front and center. Famine has forced Hansel and Gretel's parents to a drastic plan: lead the children into the woods and ditch them. Of course, whenever parents consider such dastardly things it means one parent is a step-parent. Guess which, or should I say witch because by now we know that step-mothers are secretly witches (but not true witches as we'll see).

Having heard the plan the children decide they will find a way home. Hansel leaves small pebbles along the road the first time and the parents (well, the step-witch at least) is dismayed at their return. Second time's the charm as they lead the children deeper into the woods and Hansel switches to bread which is eaten by birds. Now truly lost in the woods they stumble upon a house made of bread and cake with sugar glass for windows. Nibble-nibble-nibble and out pops a true witch. How do we know? Because
...witches have red eyes and can't see very far, but they have a keen sense of smell, like animals, and can detect when human beings are near them.
which sounds an awful lot like an albino to me. Seems folk in those days were fearful of things they didn't understand and woe to any child born to be labeled a witch. (And for a more detailed look at the idea behind while albinos are cast as villians in popular culture, check out this article fromPenn State.)

So this particular witch was smart enough to know that during a famine people would be shoving their children into the woods the way some people flush goldfish down the toilet when they tire of them. And she had the resources (being a witch, no doubt, she could conjure them) to build edible houses much like the gingerbread treats children can't resist during the holiday season.

Once lured to the house the witch throws Hansel into a pen for fattening while Gretel has to help with the household duties. The detail here that gets me is that while Hansel feasts and seems unable to use his strength to break out Gretel is fed crab shells. Crab shells. In the middle of the forest. Crab.

How Gretel fools the witch and gains her freedom owes much to the old Punch and Judy plays (that were themselves adapted from the humorous bits of lazzi performed by harlequin, or Arlequino, in 17th century Comedia del Arte). To fool the Hangman, Punch pretends not to understand what he's supposed to do. The Hangman informs him to stick his head in the noose but Punch can't seem to manage until out of frustration the Hangman sticks his head in the noose where Punch kicks the box out from under him and cheats death. Here, Gretel is asking the witch for a demonstration on how Hansel is going into the oven until the witch finally shows here to where Gretel can shove her in and bake her.

The witch dead, Hansel and Gretel ransack the witches house of gems and jewels, find their way home, and return home to their joyful father who, once again, is a widower since the step-mother died.

As a reminder that the Grimm tales came from the oral tradition this one ends with the storyteller's little tag:
My tale is done. See the mouse run. Catch it, whoever can, and then you can make a great big cap out of it's fur.
Not quite Hickory Dickory Dock, but about as meaningful.

Wednesday, April 4

Sloth

by Gilbert Hernandez
Vertigo/DC Comics 2006

Spoilers alert: About half way through. I'll let you know when we get there.

Parents moving from the city to quieter towns for the sake of giving their kids peace and relative safety may be trading off one set of evils for another. Gilbert Hernandez starts off his dark and gripping tale of teen angst by suggesting that nature abhors a vacuum, and for teens removed from a city, that vacuum leads to boredom, low existential self esteem and, perhaps inevitably, irrational suicide.

And that's just three pages in.

But Gilbert Hernandez uses this framework of teen ennui to build a story about another possibility, that a strong-willed teen named Miguel Serra has deliberately slipped into a coma for a year, and then wakes himself up, mostly unchanged. The loss of a year doesn't seemed to have changed much for Miguel of his fellow teens. Sure, his friends relationships may have been on hold -- in particular, his band which includes his girlfriend and his best friend -- but on the whole Miguel didn't seem to miss much. There's still some unanswered questions about why his mother abandoned him when he was for, whether or not his incarcerated drug-dealing father might have had something to do with her disappearance, but nothing that wasn't there when Miguel decided to drop into his dream-like coma state and chill for a bit.

Sloth is the name of Miguel's band. It's also the nickname he's been given by his homies in response to his slightly-slowed pace. To Miguel his pace isn't slow so much as it's deliberate. When the bands gets together to practice he finds he no longer has the taste for loud and fast and wants to rethink slower material. He hasn't lost emotion or feeling but adopted a more dream-like view of the world and it suits him fine.

His girlfriend Lita appears to have remained faithful to him the year he was gone, and has become something of an expert on urban legends. The one she's obsessing about the most concerns a local lemon grove where dead bodies are rumored to be buried, and where a mysterious creature called The Goatman lives. Lita gets Miguel and their bandmate Romeo to hit the orchard on a moonless night where they may or may not have spotted the mysterious creature that lives there. At one point the party is separated and when Miguel meets up he finds Romeo and Lita holding each other. He writes it off at first but the nagging suspicion that there's something between them grows. When he confront Romeo with it later he's unconvincingly evasive.

All the while Miguel dreams. He dreams of his mother, and the lemon orchard, and the peacefulness he found when he was in a coma. The coma was his escape from the banalities of the real world, from the drama and the trauma and it's beginning to look more and more attractive to him.

Here come some spoilers.

And that's when the transformation takes place, almost a transubstantiation really. A year's coma didn't change the world only his perception of the things within it, and so he drifts back into the comfort of that sleep...

And wakes up as Lita.

The second half of Sloth is actually divided into two parts, each shorter than the previous section, almost the inverse of the golden mean spiraling rapidly inward. In Lita's version of the self-induced coma she has yet to get the nerve to speak to Miguel, a silent crush that eventually finds its commonality in a love of a rock singer named Romeo X. It's a parallel universe with the same characters as before, only not. In Miguel's story there are bullies who become thugs but in Lita's coma-dream these bullies are wannabe rappers who dream of opening for Romeo X. And when Lita eventually meets her musical hero Romeo he turns out to be a compassionate nerd and she is torn in her love between him and Miguel. When Miguel confront Romeo the fight that results draws Lita into an accident that pushes her back into a coma. Romeo realizes that he's not good enough for Lita and drowns himself, slipping into a coma as Miguel rescues him. Romeo realizes there's a comfort in comaland and decides he may just stay there.

Draw what conclusions you may -- a coma as a stand-in for drugs, that escape is the universal dream of teens trapped that makes them feel helpless, that like caged animals we have created whole communities of souls driven to acts of desperation and self-destruction -- Hernandez manages to capture the contained world that is teen ennui. The sub-plot concerning the lemon grove, the urban legends and mysterious deaths only exist in Miguel's world, though Lita also dreams of the grove and the creature said to live there. It's like the Jungian idea that everyone caries their personal world into their dreams but that dream world caries commonalities that allow people to "connect" while there. In the brief chapter that is Romeo's coma the lemon grove -- which is the last panel of the book -- is his sanctuary. I may stay forever he says, and there's no reason to doubt him.

Apathy is not the answer, neither is checking out, running away, dropping out or just wishing it would all go away. None of these characters really wants to confront the issues they have before them despite all their attempts to grapple with them. At one point Miguel marvels that his grandparents argue opposite sides of the political spectrum but still love each other. He hasn't spent the time and years they have coming to terms with that idea that one can love and respect someone and still not agree with them; he hasn't the experience, the trials and errors that would give him the insight they have gained over time. Despite his deliberate, slowed pace he is still too impatient. The coma is the easy way out.

I've long known of Los Bros. Hernandez -- Gilbert and his brother Jaime created the seminal alternative comic book Love and Rockets back in the early 1980's -- so I was happy to see a new graphic novel making the recommended lists recently. In the past I preferred Jaime's stories because they felt more grounded to a landscape I understood, his approach to female characters seemed better rooted to me. Gilbert Hernandez doesn't do anything here to shake that feeling, but I was more engaged with this book of his than in any of his Palomar stories. Which is to say that I liked it, but I have reservations.

I'm getting to that point where I'm wondering about the appropriateness of certain materials for teens. I get torn because I'm all for the gore and gruesomeness being left in the Grimm tales but I go the other way when it comes to teens because I feel that there are larger issues involved. I look at the increase in violence in schools and I recognize that it's more of a societal problem than just the influences of culture, and yet that's a chicken-and-egg argument: does the society influence the violent cultural entertainments or does the entertaining violence alter the accepted culture? Part of me (the part that went to art school) likes to think of the arts as influential and transformative, but you can only live in that fantasy land for so long. The arts reflect, that's my stance, and that why I straddle the fence when it come to appropriateness.

Which is to ask the question: do I think this is appropriate for a teen aged audience? It isn't like I think they're going to go around inducing themselves into comas for escape. No, teens will do what they always have done, find whatever it takes to cope. I guess I'll take the same out that Vertigo Comics uses in the small print just below the bar code.

Suggested for Mature Readers.

Tuesday, April 3

Grimmoire 13: The Three Little Gnomes in the Forest

There's wisdom in them thar tales. This from the second paragraph:
What shall I do? Marriage is both a joy and a torture.

Apparently, the men in Grimm tales understand the perils of what will happen when they are widowed.

Here's a classic blended family. Both parents enter with daughters (no mention of how the wife was widowed, but since we all know stepmothers are evil, foul play was probably involved) and the wife makes all kinds of motions about how her hubby's girl will be the favored one. It's all about who gets to wash with milk and drink wine and who gets nothing but water and the shorthand is a bit confusing at first. Once married, hubby's daughter (the prettier one) is treated like dirt and made to bend to the whims of her nasty stepmother, that's what it comes down to.

It's winter, and to satisfy the stepmother's urges she sends her stepdaughter out in the snow in a paper dress with a half loaf of stale bread to gather strawberries. The girl protests but does as she's told. Who knows why her father doesn't protest, perhaps he's already locked in the basement.

The girl finds a cottage in the forest, the home of three gnomes. She greets them kindly, shares her bread with them and they let her into their house out of the cold. She tells them why she's out in the snow and they send her out to sweep the back porch while they decide what to do with her. Each of the gnomes bestows upon the girl a gift; one gives her the gift of beauty that grows each day; one gives the gift of coins dropping out of her mouth each time she speaks; the third gives her the gift of a king coming to take her for a wife.

Because wandering kings need strange coin-spewing waifs to take for a wife. Like they don't have enough money.

Meanwhile, as she sweeps the snow she uncovers dozens of ripe red strawberries. She collects them, thanks the gnomes for the hospitality, then trundles home to let her family knows what has happened. Of course, stepmama had assumed she was sending the girl to her death, not have her come home spitting gold so she was double-plus furious. The girls' stepsister was so envious that she begged her mother to go to the gnomes and have them bestow the same gifts on her, wearing her mother down until she agrees.

But instead of a paper dress she sews up a neat fur coat for her daughter. And instead of being pleasant she is rude and demanding when she finds the gnomes. And when she refuses to sweep the snow the gnomes know just what gifts she deserves: she will grow uglier by the day; she will spew toads when she speaks; and her last gift is to die a miserable death. How delightful!

Stepmother is even more furious and sends the girl down to the frozen pond to rinse some yarn. A king spots her and la la-la la-la. Yet this is only one of those false happy endings.

Flash forward a year. The girl is now queen and has given birth to a boy. One day while the king is away the stepmother and her daughter come and toss the girl out the window and into the river, in the misguided hope that the toad-spewer can take her place without the king noticing. There is no logic to why they would think this and their efforts could be easily found out.

But no. The queen assumes the shape of a duck and visits a kitchen boy. After a series of rhymed questions she resumes her former shape (but as a ghost) and calls for the king. The king waves his sword over her and she returns to the world of the living. Now, how to deal with the usurpers?

The king asks the stepmother What does a person deserve who drags someone out of his bed and throws him into the water? The stepmother replies: The scoundrel deserves nothing better than to be put into a barrel studded with nails on the inside, and then he should be rolled down the hill into the water. Sort of a crude Iron Maiden, if you will. Now there's a lovely image to give children.

But not one mention of the ugly girl, the one who was supposed to die a painful, hideous death. I mean, if that's what her mother got, what could have been waiting for her beyond the edges of the story? Too gruesome to include in the original tale itself, or just a flaw in the ointment?

I get the idea of the story being a lesson in good behavior paying off rich dividends, but once you get to the part where the queen is tossed in the river, transformed into a duck, then a ghost, just so the king can exact a retribution, that's where I feel things get excessive. Do we really need that part of the story? The stepmother's daughter is spouting toads already, we don't need a revenge plot added to the mix. Why didn't the witchy stepmother go and try to mess with the trolls if the story was looking for balance? I'd have much preferred to see those guys bestow a few gifts onto her and leave the queen alone. For once.

Monday, April 2

How Doth Chaucer Blog?

It was only a matter of time before the dead started blogging. Go on, follow the link to Geoffrey Chaucer Hath a Blog and see what the man is up to these days.

Personally, if someone can point me in the direction of Jules Verne's blog I'd greatly appreciate it. He seemed ahead of his time, perhaps he's been hosting a blog for the last 130 years or so. Though knowing him he's probably running it on a Babbage platform.

Tagged, Double-Tagged Even!

I suppose I should have seen it coming when an author I reviewed called my rambling stream-of-consciousness take on his book "brainy". Now I get hit by the tag-team (pun intended) of Eisha and Jules over at 7Imp as both a "Thinking Blog" and for another meme concerning the non-lit blogs I frequent.

Yikes.

The Thinking Blog thing has me a bit stumped as I've been watching all my thinking blogs get tagged before my very eyes. And since I don't believe "tag backs" are fair I'm going to have to give that post a little more thought than my non-lit post.

My five non-lit blogs, in no particular order...
  • ModMom is my secret doorway into the world Mid-Century Modern art and design. Well, it's not so secret, just my secret. Maybe secret isn't the word. ModMom celebrates the art and style of an era that taps directly into the innocence and nostalgia of my elementary school days. It showcases the boldness in design that briefly promised us a future of unique furnishings in 1970's colors that weren't only avocado and burnt orange. It also rounds up contemporary artists, designers, businesses and retailers who are capturing and reviving that spirit today and bringing it back for retro hipsters.
  • Keri Smith's The Wish Jar may get a double-hit here because I think of this as both a creative artist's on-line journal and a Thinking Blog. Keri calls herself "Author, Illustrator, Guerrilla Artist" but so much of what she posts are also meditations on the creative act. In February she participated in "A Thing A Day" month by creating something and posting it without fail. Many of the "things" could be viewed as the kind of creative exercises an artist might do when feeling stumped in their regular work, but with Keri each is carefully considered, grouped each week by theme, and presented almost like silent lessons in jump-starting your brain. Or my brain at least.
  • This one's a bit off the rails. It's Seth Godin's Blog and perhaps one of the oldest blogs I've kept tabs with. Seth is a marketer, but he's also an innovator. He writes about the ideas surrounding marketing from a point of view that takes common sense and turns it on it's head. Seth's books looked like someone misplaced some fiction titles in the business section, the art was fresh and fun and the titles themselves were not like most business titles: The Big Red Fez, Free Prize Inside, The Purple Cow, All Marketers Are Liars. What's not to like? At that point I actually had to rethink my position on books in the business section and began to read both his blog and the places he takes me for views on how people think and act in the marketplace. If you read this post on brands and mythology with an eye toward Harry Potter you'll know why I keep checking him out.
  • Time for the out-of-the-blue segment. When I was in fifth grade I wanted to be an animator. Lacking the actual ability to draw, and not having the foresight at that time to see that digital cartoons were on the horizon in a dozen years, I gave up the dream but never the interest. To that end I like to check in on the blogs of animators, artists who work in animation, and a handful of animation student who seem promising to me. Lorelay Bove is a character animation student at Cal Arts, a college founded by Disney that focuses primarily on animation. Her works reminds me of Mary Blair, going back to that Mid-Century thing again. She works both traditionally (with paint) and digitally but prefers the hand-drawn and when viewed side-by-side you can see the warmth that always seems to be lacking in digital work by artists. She's not a frequent poster -- she is a student after all -- but when she does the illustrations she posts are like little tea time pauses in a text-bound day.
  • Finally, I cook. Five nights a week. I'm not great, but I can hold my own. I have any number of places that I like to visit for recipes and general info but Coconut & Lime is the place I go to when I want a good kick in the rut. Rachel Rappaport has been featured on NPR and was the winner of "best original recipes" category in the 2006 Food Blog Awards. You know, I didn't even know that until just this moment when I was double-checking her info for this post. Unlike other food blogs where people post their variations on established recipes, Rachel always seems to be exploring the possibilities and her recipes stand out as a result. Well-illustrated, nicely designed, it's a good blog all around. And it tastes good, too.
So that's my five. Passing it forward, I have the same problems as with the Thinking Blogger tag: everyone I know appears to have been hit already. The problem of being low man on the totem pole. If you're reading this, and you haven't been tagged, and you want to participate please (a) feel free to do so and (b) give me a hard time in the comments for not tagging you properly.

Grimmoire 12: Rapunzel

Perhaps the only tale I'm aware of where the title character is named after a lettuce her mother was craving while pregnant. I knew a girl once whose family nickname for her was Pickles, I wonder if that was the same thing.

I realize these stories don't usually require, demand or hold up under scrutiny but there's a funny little incongruity at the beginning of this one. The husband and wife live in a small home with a small window that looked over an herb garden. The herb garden is surrounded by a high wall. I'm going to guess that the home was on a high hill in order to see out a small window over a high wall at the herb garden. How else to explain the wife being able to see those delish herbs?

And one herb in particular: Rampion. Also known in those parts of the world as Rapunzel. Or corn salad, or mache, or lamb's lettuce or any of around 40 other varieties of small-leaf lettuce.

So the wife is pregnant and she has a craving for a salad, not any old salad but a rampion salad. The nature of pregnancy cravings being what they are, and the understanding of what will happen if the husbands do not do everything humanly possible to satisfy those cravings, the husband slips over the wall to steal some rampion.

I like this little detail, because it sets up a very complex relationship. The herb garden belongs to a character referred to as Mother Gothel which, during Grimm's time, was a common term for a godmother. It isn't clear whether she's the godmother of either the husband or wife, or if she becomes the godmother of the child who will be Rapunzel, but the woman isn't referred to as a witch, nor is she a stranger. So why steal it? Was hubby so frantic, so desperate that he didn't think Mama G would notice? Was he just afraid of women in general? So many interesting questions!

Mother G catches hubby and says, sure, you can have the lettuce, but when the child turns 12 she's mine. Hubby, desperate and fearful, agrees to the terms. Just like that, he trades away his child at the age she would have been packed off for the factory to a women he fears in exchange for some lettuce. How does this guy live with himself for the next dozen years?

Baby is born, named after lettuce, grows up, turns 12, is handed over to Mother G and put in a high tower for no good reason for the rest of her days with nothing to do but grow her hair. Fairy tale logic, pretty standard stuff, and the story plods along the way most people recognize it. Wandering Prince sees Mama G call for Rapunzel to let down her hair, sees the beauty at the top, falls instantly in love (natch) and climbs his way up where they make plans to elope.

Now, if you learned this story the way I did as a child -- as a Fractured Fairy Tale from the Rocky and Bulwinkle Show -- then you know that the Prince and Rapunzel get away and everything's great until Rapunzel gets pregnant and has a craving for Mama G's rampion, thus continuing the cycle. Funny, but since I figured the story ended with the Prince rescuing Rapunzel there it seemed natural to poke fun at the happy ending.

What happy ending?

In this Grimm version the Prince and Rapunzel prove to be a matched set of numbskulls: Every time you come you must bring a skein of silk with you, and I will weave it into a ladder says Rapunzel. I can forgive Rapunzel for not having much of an education, but the Prince could have come up with a better idea. Why not bring a real rope? Why not build a ladder? Heck, the story says there's a hook outside the window that she uses to hitch her braid onto so that all comers can climb up the tower, why not a pair of scissors to hack off the hair and use it to climb down?

Because I suspect the Prince actually liked his little care-free conjugal visits. A woven ladder that needed to be 60 feet long made from silk... that could take years to produce at one skein a visit. They couldn't have been big because the Prince needed to haul them up with him. No, I believe the Price was scamming on Rapunzel with no real intention of getting her out of the tower.

Which is fine, because he doesn't. Mama G catches drift of what's happening and banishes Rapunzel to the farthest reaches of the Shwarzwald to wander the rest of her days. The Prince arrives and climbs up the tower to find Mama G then leaps in horror into the bushes below where the thorns poke out his eyes.

The blind Prince wanders many years until he stumbles upon Rapunzel who is toting a pair of twins. Ach! So Mama G had every reason to be furious, the Prince got Rapunzel knocked up. The Prince has paid for his philandering and kind-hearted Rapunzel, glad that the father of her children has come to his senses, weeps for joy, her tears landing on his afflicted orbs and returning his sight by magic!

Now we get the happy ending. The Prince and Rapunzel return to his kingdom where he assumes his royal duties and everyone is happy and no one questions where he's been all these years. It's wonderful to think that when you're royalty that you can vanish for years and your kingdom will remain in tact and primed for your return. Especially when you vanish without notice, not like some of those other silly kings and princes who dash off to fight in Crusades and at least send word every once in a while that they're coming home soon.

All because of a little lettuce.

Grimmoire 10: Riffraff

A word or two before the proceedings take place. First, while I have been keeping up with my Grimm-a-Day reading I haven't been as on top of things regarding my posts. This week I'm going to try for a little catch-up posting so it may get a little thick around mid-week.

Second, I really appreciate the shout-outs coming from other corners of the kidlit blogosphere, specifically Jules and Eisha at 7Imp, Brooke at The Brookeshelf, and Monica over at Educating Alice for their encouragement, support and generally pointing some of you this direction. Of all the things I wasn't doing to get attention, this project of mine to read all the Grimm stories seems to have hit a nerve and now I have the added impetus to not let it wane.

Now, how about a little "Riffraff."

This tale could easily be titled "Ruffians" or "Rogues" or "Scoundrels" and features Chickens in the title role. Yes, Renegade Chickens on the loose!

A mean-spirited Roster and a Hen get it in their heads to go up the hill and eat all the ripe nuts before Squirrel can hide them away for winter. Yes, instead of stealing them they just eat them all. And because of that they're too bloated to move.

Rooster's brilliant idea is to use the nutshells to build a carriage. When Hen realizes she's supposed to pull it she refuses. When Duck comes along and realizes the Chickens have eaten all the nuts (wait, weren't those Squirrel's nuts? Is Duck as bad as the Chickens, only slower?) he's furious. Rooster insists Duck pull him and his Hen, engaging him in a cockfight (which he naturally wins) to determine who's pulling whom.

With Duck hitched to the nutshell carriage the crew pick up a Needle and a Pin alongside the road who have had too much to drink.

A Needle and Pin. Drunk. This is another of those fine instances where the Grimm tales feature inanimate objects that just make my head spin sometimes, especially when they're hitching a ride roadside from a Duck pulling a pair of Chickens in a carriage made of nutshell. They say reality is stranger than fiction, but you can't say that around the Brothers Grimm.

It's getting late. The party of five decides to stop at an inn. The Chickens sweet talk the Innkeeper into letting them all stay the night with the promise of handing over a Duck egg and a Chicken egg in the morning. Ah, so nice to be able to trade off potential offspring in exchange for a night at the inn. But if that isn't a shock, in the morning the Chickens wake up before everyone else and eat the eggs themselves and ditch the shells in the fire! Then they take the still-passed-out Needle and place it in the innkeeper's towel, place the Pin in the seat of the Innkeeper's chair, and ditch without paying.

These Chickens is Bad to the Bone.

Duck wakes up, realizes he's been ditched, and before he can get hit with the bill hightails it for the river and floats home on his own.

The Innkeeper wakes up and washes his face and... you cringe at the horror before it happens as he reaches for his towel. His face gouged, his inn empty, he goes for the comfort of his pipe but as he reaches for an ember to light his pipe... the eggshells explode into his face! It's all too much, he needs a seat but... yup, right on the Pin.

The. End.

That's right. The Chickens get away and the Innkeeper is left with the lesson not to trust talking cannibalistic animals. Who knows what becomes of the Needle and Pin. I think this is the first instance in the Grimm tales (though I doubt it will be the last) where it seems like it's building up to a moral lesson and it doesn't. The Innkeeper does nothing wrong -- unless you count the trusting of farm animals wrong -- and is punished for his efforts.

It's gems like this that make me wonder about how these stories were told, and when, and to whom and how they played with an audience. Was this something a bunch of guys came up with at the inn one soggy night to kill the time and it became sort of the village joke story that everyone told and had a good laugh at? Was there some sun-baked farmer who, after 18 hours of back-breaking labor, hunkered down along side the bed of his scruffy young children and, by the light of a candle making him look like the Crypt Keeper, did he hiss out this bedtime tale to wig out his children?

And what happened to those kids when they grew up?

Sunday, April 1

Today at the Bluebird Cafe

A Branchful of Birds
by Deborah Ruddell
illustrated by Joan Rankin
Margaret K. McElderry Books/Simon & Schuster 2007










It's all-you--can-eat at the Bluebird Cafe,
a grasshopper-katydid-cricket buffet,
with berries and snails and bluebottle fly,
a sip of the lake and a bite of the sky.
Oh, but it starts off so promising.

This collection of poems about birds could have been swell if it hadn't suffered from that common malady of uneven rhymes and herky-jerky meter.

If I'm repeating myself, forgive me, but if you're going to write rhyming poetry it needs to have a natural rhythm. I'm not going to be a stickler for meter unless you start out a poem with it but drop it when it becomes inconvenient half way through the poem. If you are going to hold to the meter it still needs to sound natural.

I call it the read-aloud test, it needs to have a read-aloud rhythm. That is, a child with reading fluency should be able to pick up the poem and read it cold and capture the rhythm. They can falter in the first line or two as they get the hang of things, but it shouldn't be catching them off-guard along the way. The fun in reading poetry for kids is in the wordplay, it's in the cleverness of the beat where they (as readers or listeners) can follow along. The words need to roll off the tongue or dance in their head.

Not sound like the equivalent of a teen driver leaning how to drive a stick.

The names we know, they know the rules and they know how to bend them. Shel Silverstien and Jerry Moss understood this, and no surprise both were also lyricists; Karla Kuskin gets it; Edward Lear even in his most forced verse gets it; Maurice Sendak, certainly; Prelutsy, Florian and Stevenson all grok the rhythm. And yet book after book of rhyming text -- poetry and picture book -- roll off the presses with awkward phrasing and broken meter and all the prettiest pictures in the world won't save them.

Why? Why, if compelled to write in verse, wouldn't a writer want to make their verse the best it could possibly be? There's no sin in striving to become classic, why settle? What is the point of the exercise if the only concern is the rhyme? What's the reason?

Seminar after seminar, listing after listing in the Writer's Market, editors beg and scream: Please! No rhyming texts! And yet, these same publishers are the guiltiest of parties. I won't place all the blame on the writers.

Another book of poems, trashed;
Another round of hopes, dashed.